HOT CHARACTERS - CHECKLIST
Here we will start to create a database for easy reference of the most collected popular characters and their earliest appearances.

X-23

EARLY APPEARANCES

February 2004:
NYX (2003) #3 - 'Wannabe, Part Three' 1ST APP - 40,000 COPIES

July 2004:
NYX (2003) #4 - 'Wannabe, Part Four' - 2ND APP - 37,000 COPIES

September 2004:
NYX (2003) #5 - 'Wannabe, Part Five' - 3RD APP - 35,000 COPIES

December 2004:
Uncanny X-Men (1963) #450 - 'The Cruelest Cut, Part 1 of 2' - 4TH APP - 101,000 COPIES
Uncanny X-Men (1963) #451 - 'Impediments' - 5TH APP - 97,000 COPIES

February 2005:
X-Men (1991) #165 - 'Hark How the Bells--!' - 6TH APP - 86,000 COPIES

March 2005:
X-23 (2005) #1 - 'Innocence Lost: Part One' - 7TH APP - 68,000 COPIES
X-23 (2005) #2 - 'Innocence Lost: Part Two' - 8TH APP - 56,000 COPIES

April 2005:
Marvel Team-Up (2004) #5 - 'Golden Child, Part Five' = 9TH APP - 28,000 COPIES
Uncanny X-Men (1963) #455 - 'Not Dead Yet?! - World's End, Part 1 of 5' - 10TH APP - 88,000 COPIES
Uncanny X-Men (1963) #456 - 'On Ice! - World's End, Part 2 of 5' - 11TH APP - 86,000 COPIES
X-23 (2005) #3 - 'Innocence Lost: Part Three' - 12TH APP - 54,000 COPIES

May 2005:
Marvel Team-Up (2004) #6 - 'Golden Child, Part Six' - 13TH APP - 24,000 COPIES
Uncanny X-Men (1963) #457 - 'Cutting Edge! - World's End, Part 3 of 5' - 14TH APP - 86,000 COPIES
X-23 (2005) #4 - 'Innocence Lost: Part Four' - 15TH APP - 54,000 COPIES

June 2005:
Uncanny X-Men (1963) #458 - 'The Enemy of My Enemy: World's End, Part 4 of 5' -16TH APP - 86,000 COPIES
X-23 (2005) #5 - 'Innocence Lost: Part Five' - 17TH APP - 54,000 COPIES

July 2005:
Uncanny X-Men (1963) #459 - 'Bad Company: World's End, Conclusion' - 18TH APP - 83,000 COPIES
X-23 (2005) #6 - 'Innocence Lost: Part Six' - 19TH APP - 51,000 COPIES

August 2005:
Uncanny X-Men (1963) #460 - 'Resurrections & Reunions' - 20TH APP - 82,000 COPIES

September 2005:
NYX (2003) #6 - 'Wannabe, Part Six' - 21ST APP - 36,000 COPIES

October 2005:
NYX (2003) #7 - 'Wannabe, Part Seven' - 22ND APP - 34,000 COPIES

2005:
Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe: X-Men 2005 (2005) nn - 22,000 COPIES



RAREST RATIO VARIANTS

X-23 (MARVEL) 3

X-23 #1 (2010) 1:75 MARKO DJURDJEVIC VAR

X-23 #4 (2010) 1:50 MARKO DJURDJEVIC VAR

X-23 #15 (2011) 1:50 MARVEL COMICS 50TH ANNIV PATRICK ZIRCHER VAR